Hijab ban amounts to direct discrimination

Tags: Race Discrimination, Employment Law, Employment Tribunal, Hijab

Despite efforts to encourage diversity in the workplace, employers can still get caught out by the equality legislation. This has been demonstrated by the recent decision in Bougnaoui and another v Micropole SA where a ban on an employee wearing her Islamic headscarf (hijab) was deemed to be direct discrimination. 

Ms Bougnaoui, a Muslim woman who worked for Micropole an operating company in France, was dismissed when she refused to comply with her employers request for the removal of her headscarf when in contact with customers. The request was made following a customer complaint. 

The court in the first instance, and upon appeal, held that the employers practice was not discriminatory as it was a “genuine and determining occupation requirement”. 

However, when the matter was referred to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) the Advocate General (AG) concluded that the employee’s dismissal for wearing an Islamic headscarf at work was directly discriminatory on grounds of religion or belief. It was clear that a non-Muslim employee would not have been treated in the same way.  

The AG added that discrimination would only be lawful, i.e. be based on an “occupational requirement”, when it was genuine and absolutely necessary. The example given was for health & safety reasons. 

Conclusion 

This decision highlights the need for employers to ensure that commercial needs are not put before the needs of employees who fall within the definition of having a ‘protected characteristic’ within the meaning of the Equality Act 2010. 

This is, of course, a European decision so its relevance may be debateable once the Brexit negotiations commence.  

Here at SCE we have a wealth of experience in dealing with similar issues If you need advice in managing a discrimination complaint please me on 0113 3 50 40 30 or at samira.cakali@scesolicitors.co.uk

No Comments

Add a Comment

LATEST LEGAL UPDATES:

  • Clearing the Air on Commercial Disputes

    Tags: Commercial Litigation, Commercial Disputes, Contract, Time Limits, Breach of Contract, Court, Remedies, Damages, Specific Performance, Rescission

    Navigating your way through a commercial dispute can be time consuming and stressful. Disruption caused to your business and the impact on managerial time can be costly.

    Commercial disputes are becoming increasingly commonplace, and therefore it is essential that businesses obtain strategic advice as soon as possible in any dispute so that they can minimise the impact on the business.

    Generally speaking, the law takes the view that a contract is formed between parties when one party makes an offer to another who accepts the offer. The parties have to be certain as to the terms of the contract, there has to be an intention to create a contract and there has to be ‘consideration’ i.e. there has to be some value.

    A contract does not need to be in writing or signed for it to … more

    

Reviews and Ratings for solicitor Samira Cakali, Leeds